Comprehensive vs. Collision Auto Insurance Coverage in 2024 (Differences Explained)

Comprehensive vs. collision auto insurance coverage are two key options that you should consider for vehicle protection. Comprehensive coverage protects against non-collision incidents like theft, vandalism, and weather-related damage, while collision coverage pays for repairs after an accident, regardless of fault.

The choice between the two types of insurance coverage depends on factors such as your vehicle’s value and in accordance with your budget constraints.

For you to get the best rates, you must compare quotes from leading providers such as Progressive, Geico, and State Farm to ensure you’re getting the right protection for the best price.

Read More: Does auto insurance cover damage done by a shopping cart?

Get fast and cheap auto insurance coverage today with our quote comparison tool above.

What is Collision Coverage

Collision coverage is an optional car insurance policy that helps pay for repairs or replacement of your vehicle if it’s damaged in an accident, regardless of fault. Unlike basic liability insurance, which only covers damage to other vehicles or property, collision coverage protects your own car.

If your vehicle is damaged in an accident, your insurance will cover the repair costs minus your deductible. If the repair costs exceed the vehicle’s value, your insurer will declare it “totaled” and provide compensation based on the car’s value.

Comprehensive vs. Collision Auto Insurance Coverage Monthly Rates by Provider

Collision coverage also applies in cases where you were not at fault, with your insurer covering the repair costs and seeking reimbursement from the other driver’s insurance.

It is especially useful in hit-and-run accidents where the at-fault driver is unknown, as it covers damage to your car even if the responsible driver cannot be identified. This coverage ensures you are financially protected regardless of who caused the accident.

Read More: Does my auto insurance cover damage to my own car if I am at fault in an accident?

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

What is Comprehensive Coverage

Comprehensive coverage is an optional insurance policy that covers your vehicle in a broader range of situations – including storm damage, theft, and vandalism.

When you just buy collision coverage, your vehicle is only covered in an accident. With comprehensive coverage, you get extended coverage for situations outside of accidents.

Differences Between Collision and Comprehensive Auto Insurance

Type of coverage	Purpose	What's covered	What's not covered
Comprehensive	Covers repair/replacement costs if the car is damaged by anything other than a collision with another vehicle or someone's property	Vandalism, theft, fire, hail, falling objects, animals, water damage, and much more	Crashes into objects and accidents involving two or more vehicles (regardless of fault); see "Full Coverage"
Collision	Covers repair/replacement costs if the car is damaged as the result of a collision with another vehicle or someone else's property	Crashes into objects and accidents involving two or more vehicles (regardless of fault)	Vandalism, theft, fire, hail, falling objects, animals, water damage, and much more; see "Full Coverage"
Full Coverage	While not really a type of coverage itself, this term is often used to describe comprehensive and collision coverage when bundled together	Everything shown in "Comprehensive" and "Collision"	Damage to other vehicles, medical expenses, lost wages as the result of an accident, and numerous other expenses which drivers need other types of insurance to cover

Comprehensive coverage provides protection against a variety of risks not typically covered by basic car insurance. Some of the major things covered by comprehensive insurance include vandalism, theft, flood damage, and damage from fallen objects like tree branches.

It also covers damage caused by hail, fires, and other non-collision events, offering broad protection for your vehicle against unexpected circumstances.

In many cases, comprehensive coverage also covers other vehicles you drive – like rental cars or a friend’s car. Explore how affordable comprehensive auto insurance coverage protects your vehicle from unexpected risks while fitting your budget.

Should I Buy Both Comprehensive and Collision Coverage

Basic liability insurance is required by law, but collision and comprehensive coverage are optional. While these coverages come at a higher cost, they provide extensive protection for your vehicle. A comparison of comprehensive auto insurance shows how both cover vandalism, theft, and accidents, offering full coverage vs collision coverage for more peace of mind in almost any situation.

It’s important to understand the difference between collision and comprehensive coverage—comprehensive covers non-collision incidents like theft, hail, or vandalism, while collision covers accident repairs.

Also, consider the comprehensive deductible vs. collision deductible when choosing your policy. Comprehensive vs collision coverage with Progressive provides flexibility and options depending on your needs and vehicle value.

Ultimately, your decision will depend on your comfort with risk and the value of your vehicle. If you’re willing to pay more today for more protection, both coverages may be worth it. If not, removing one or both could save you money, though it leaves you with higher financial risk in certain situations.

Read more: Does auto insurance cover vandalism?

You May Be Required to Carry Collision or Comprehensive Coverage

In some cases, you may be required to carry both collision and comprehensive coverage for the insured vehicle. For example, if you finance or lease your vehicle, the lender or dealership will usually require you to have these coverages.

This is to protect their investment in your vehicle, as it serves as collateral for the loan. Understanding the difference between collision and comprehensive auto insurance can help clarify your coverage options.

From hail to vandalism, comprehensive insurance coverage may help pay for repairs. Know what to consider when deciding your deductible. Learn more: https://t.co/fYVJX8sEEO pic.twitter.com/eYVyljWVLF

— USAA (@USAA) November 28, 2022

While comprehensive vs. collision loss covers non-collision damages like theft or weather, collision coverage vs. comprehensive coverage specifically handles accident-related repairs.

Once your vehicle is paid off, you can choose to remove these coverages, as the lender no longer has a claim on your vehicle. Learn more about what are the different types of auto insurance coverage to find the right protection for your vehicle and make informed decisions about your policy.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

When Should You Drop Collision and Comprehensive Coverage

You buy car insurance to protect your vehicle, which is why most people choose comprehensive vs collision auto insurance. Generally, it’s a good idea to include both as long as you can afford the premiums. However, there are situations where you may want to drop collision and comprehensive coverage to lower your costs.

A common rule of thumb is the 10% rule. This suggests dropping comprehensive vs collision auto insurance if the cost of the premiums exceeds 10% of your car’s book value.

For instance, if your car is worth $3,000, and your premiums cost $320 per year, it may be worth dropping this extra coverage. You could also look for cheap comprehensive and collision insurance if you still want to maintain coverage while saving money.

If you’re comfortable with assuming more risk and need to cut costs, dropping optional coverage might be a good option for you. Discover how affordable collision auto insurance coverage can protect your vehicle and help you save money with options that fit your budget and needs.

Comprehensive vs. Collision Auto Insurance: Making the Right Choice

Collision coverage pays for damage to your vehicle if it is involved in an accident, regardless of who is at fault. Comprehensive coverage protects your vehicle from non-accident-related incidents such as theft, flooding, vandalism, and damage caused by falling branches.

When we are to compare comprehensive coverage vs. full coverage, it is best and essential for us to understand that full coverage generally includes both comprehensive and collision coverage.

Additionally, comprehensive and collision coverage are often optional, this will allow the drivers to select the policies that best suit their needs.

Drivers concerned about specific incidents, such as hit-and-run accidents, may benefit from hit-and-run comprehensive or collision coverage, which provides protection when the responsible party cannot be identified.

While having both types of coverage offers extensive protection, some drivers of older vehicles may consider removing collision coverage to lower their premiums, particularly if the cost of coverage exceeds the car’s value.

To achieve optimal protection, as a policyholder adding both comprehensive and collision coverage is ideal. However, for older vehicles, dropping these optional coverages might be a practical choice based on the vehicle’s value and the driver’s budget.

Read more: Understanding How Auto Insurance Works

Start comparing total coverage auto insurance rates by entering your ZIP code below.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption